Bishop Matz:  7/10/1889 – 8/9/1917

Rev. Cornelius Enders, OSB: 1898 – 1899

Rev. Lawrence Haas, OSB: 1899

Rev. Antonine Hitenach, OSB (possible):  1911-1914

Rev. Robert Murray, OSB:  1914-1919

Rev. Regis Barrett, OSB: 1920-1926

Rev. Albert Shaller, OSB: 1926-1931

Rev. Matthew Connelly, OSB: 1941 (no bio)

Rev. Charles Forsyth, OSB: 1941

Rev. Layton, OSB: 1942

Rev. Maurus Zabolitsky, OSB: 1943-1946, 1947-1949

Rev. Paulinus Hammer, OSB: 1946-1947

Rev. Claude Roberts, OSB: 1949

Rev. Joseph Hannan, OSB: 1949-1956, 1960-1961

Rev. Vincent Peter, OSB: 1956-1957

Father Martin Arno, OSB: 1957-1960, 1966-1968

Rev. Peter Hudson, OSB: 1964-1966 (no bio)

Rev. Michael Walsh: 1968-1970

Rev. Kenneth Funk: 1970-1974

Rev. David Sobieszczk: 1974 (no bio)

Rev. James Morgan: 1974-1975

Rev. Peter Urban, OSB: 1975-1986

Rev. Leonard Urban, OSB: 1975-1986

Rev. John McCormick:  1986-1988

Rev. Donald C. Willette: 1988-1991

Deacon Martin Sanchez: 1989-1992

Rev. Luis Garcia, J.C.L.: 1991-1995 (no bio)

Deacon Daniel Marthe: 1992-1995 (no bio)

Rev. G. Timothy Gaines, V.F.: 1995-2000

Rev. Robert Whipkey: 2000-2007

Rev. Hernan Florez:  2008 – 2016

Deacon James Devlin:  2008-2011

Rev. Robert Wedow: 2016 – Present

Deacon Roger Creel: 2019-2021

Deacon James Mackin: 2023-Present

Deacon Tim Vaughn: 2023-Present